For anyone who's thinking should I shouldn't I change their Sierra diff for the BMW one let me give you my experience.
I built my Sigma 150 some time ago now but was very disappointed at all the whines clunks shunts and various other noises coming from the tranmission. I took the diff to Phil at Road and Race who worked his magic on it but even he said due to the very make up of it and the fact it was in a Caterham it was never going to be that quiet.
I use mine for only road driving and I know I'm not one of these dyed in the wool die-hards who say you have to expect this and it's all part of the experience of driving these cars, I just don't agree. I mean lets face it theyr'e not cheap to buy even as a kit although I'm not complaining about this, no one made me get one it was my choice. But having bought and built it I didn't expect it to sound like an old tractor going along the road.
Anyhow after listening to other peoples views thoughts and advice I decided to go for it and get the open BMW transmission fitted at CC Midlands last Thursday. Boy what a difference it's almost competely silent, just a very very slight whine in third, hardely noticeably and no clunks, a real pleasure to drive.
I can't guarantee this would be the same for everyones car but for what it's worth that's
my experience, I'm really pleased I took the plunge.
Edited by - Pete-B on 27 Sep 2011 22:34:40