I am currently on my second starter motor. I've only had the type with the solenoid on the bottom, which Caterham introduced, to get round the problem with the old one where it would occasionally not work. This was thought to be due to heat affecting the solenoid, but has turned out to be due to a hairline fracture in a contact.
The heat cause was the reason why a "solenoid underneath" design was introduced.
My first starter was replaced under guarantee, but my second has now gone the same way. I am going to see what Caterham can come up with, but if they are going to send me another exactly the same as I already have, I'm not sure I want it. I don't need the aggro of waiting while it decides to go again.
Therefore, I was thinking of either taking my current one apart and seeing if there is anything actually wrong, or else trying to get hold of the previous version and do the mod which stops the problem on that one.
Tim, if it's not actually a Rover part, that's not a problem; just want to find out what its part number is should I want to get one.
Cheers,
Nick (aka Nick G, when using other computer)