Definitely not the diff, which is a BMW LSD unit and has a reputation for being quiet, noise comes from front lhs of gearbox and is worse from passenger seat The mx5 gearbox does however seem to have a reputation for being noisy, it sounds like layshaft rattle on overrun and the courtesy 310 i borrowed was not dissimilar, very noisy, both have light flywheels Oil? When i bought then car the previous owner had missed adding the top bush on the gear linkage, causing it be be sloppy, when i lifted the levers cover to fix this it was full of oil, although i understand this is a separate housing from the main case so not completely conclusive. I suspect it would have seized by now if it was empty, i drive it in the manner intended.