Jump to content
Click here if you are having website access problems ×
  • entries
    6
  • comments
    30
  • views
    161

Insurance quotes, July 2015


AntonyH

10,512 views

Insurance prices and companies is something that always comes up on Blatchat, and it's always a bit of a struggle to find which thread has which information, so I figured I'd put my numbers in a blog post so as to be able to find them rapidly in future.

So, here's the July 2015 numbers:

2005 Roadsport SV / 1.8K / 140bhp / 7,000 road miles / fully comp / self+MrsH / garaged / suburbia / licences since 1989 and 1995 / no points / no convictions / one DVLA-aware medical condition / legal fee cover / no track / Caterham owners since 2012.

Excesses are total / windscreen replacement / windscreen repair, wherever we got that far on the call.

Company Price Excesses Notes
Adrian Flux £205.00 (£100 / £75 / £0)  
A-Plan £209.00 (£200 / £80 / £20)  
Peter James £212.01 (£150 / £75 / £10) Includes UK breakdown cover plus 35 days EU breakdown cover
Glynwood £217.00 (£150 / £90)  
Lloyd & Whyte £228.27 (£150 / £90 / £0) 10,000 miles!
MSM £275.53 (£150 / £75) 7,500 miles. Includes 3rd party cover for driving other cars. Mirrors NCD on MrsH's sensible car (proof needed)
Crosby £282.51 (£150)  
REIS £364.89 (£250 / £50)

"If you're not going to be using it for track days, ours probably isn't the policy..."
7,000 miles is the absolute max they'll quote for.

Osbourne & Sons £371 or more... --

"Can't beat £228, ours starts at £371"
Anything >5,000 miles is "unlimited mileage"

Footman James £426.67 (£175)  
2gether Insurance* -- --

"Not going to be able to get near £228"

Frank Pickles -- -- Couldn't quote last year due to two claims on MrsH's sensible car (neither our fault!), so I didn't bother asking this year.

 

*2gether were recommended to me by someone on facebook; the call lasted about 3 minutes until I told the nice lady the renewal I'd been offered was £228, when she said she'd not waste my time any further! I wish Footman James had said the same, that would have saved me 20 minutes.

It was a tricky choice this year.

Peter James offered inclusive breakdown cover which would have saved about £35 elsewhere (Autoaid); Fluxy quoted an incredibly good price, with a tiny excess, reasonable screen excess and zero excess on screen repairs (most of the others have a £10 excess); A-plan and Glynwood were both very competitive too, although A-plan's £20 screen repair excess counts against them, as we've needed 2 repairs in the prior 3 years.

7,000 miles seems to be a sticking point for some insurers; for REIS it's the absolute limit of road mileage they'll cover, and therefore "it's loading the premium up"; another of the cheapest four gave me a great price for 7,000 (as you can see) but similarly couldn't give me a price at all for 10,000. I can't remember who that was now, sadly.

In the end, Lloyd & Whyte have my business again, partly due to the hassle-free way they just handled a stone chip repair; mostly for the fact their policy includes a ridiculous 10,000 miles - which I won't get close to, but I might get near to 7,000 this year so that massive headroom means piece of mind. Who knows, it might also open up the option of a European road trip?

2 Comments


Recommended Comments

I've had the misfortune using Adrian Flux. What a mistake.

Incompetent, slow, slow, slow.

Do not document information and take more money after committed.

 

Footman James were good. Too late to change to them now.

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...